Sign in to submit new ideas and vote
Get Started

Bring Back The Old Sheet Picker for Copy/Move Row Automations

Options
13»

Comments

  • zealvert
    zealvert ✭✭✭✭
    edited 11/08/23
    Options

    Hi everyone.

    I also submitted the same issue a while ago.

    With all due respect, it's like asking someone to go on a night-drive across a barren hinterland, with their headlights turned off!

    I hope it's resolved soonest.

    fyi... @Genevieve P. @Andrée Starå

  • Mike TV
    Mike TV ✭✭✭✭✭✭
    Options

    @Genevieve P.

    I spent 20 minutes trying to set up a Move Row automation today because it kept telling me the exact same search was not found for 20 minutes, until it finally was.

    Nobody seems happy with this change. Can you bump this up the chain please?

  • Linda Hoydic
    Linda Hoydic ✭✭✭✭
    Options

    What is the solution when the Search function will not find the sheet you want to copy a row to? While I just created the new sheet, I've refreshed, typed the name exactly as the sheet name, tried partial information and to no avail, the search function will NOT find the sheet I need to use. I suppose I could manually copy to build my new sheet, but going forward I need the automation. HELP!!!!!

  • Mike TV
    Mike TV ✭✭✭✭✭✭
    edited 11/17/23
    Options

    @Linda Hoydic

    I'm beginning to believe whatever database the search is querying isn't updated in real time but is updated on a cycle. Usually what I'm doing on my end is setting up an Archive sheet. So I'll create a copy of my working sheet, rename it, and then clear out all the rows. Then I will attempt to create a Move Row Automation right away and the search won't find my sheet.

    In my experience with setting up these archive sheets, sometimes it takes the search 10mins before it will find my newly created sheet, sometimes 15mins, but up to 20mins. There's no rhyme or reason so my guess is they have it set up to run twice an hour to add new sheets to the database that is being queried on the search. So sometimes you're lucky that your sheet will be found in the search pretty quickly and some times it can take 20mins or more before the search will find it.

    Edit: I'd just like to add that if I am correct that this is entirely not acceptable for people trying to design sheets in real time.

  • Adam Murphy
    Adam Murphy ✭✭✭✭
    Options

    I waited 3 months, got frustrated with this "upgraded feature" for the millionth time and came back to see if any progress on simply reverting this ridiculousl awful "enhancement". I have to say that see this comment from Smartsheet as an update is beyond insulting:


    "Thank you for providing your feedback on the updated search experience in Move and Copy row workflows. While we have no current plans to change this feature, we want to hear more about your individual experiences. Please keep commenting and voting on this request, identifying how you want the sheet picker to improve so we can review your feedback as we make future decisions in this area."


    Translation: We don't care that you're unhappy, and despite many users citing their multiple issues with this "enhancement" we simply will not do anything about it and ask that you please just keep complaining and maybe, MAYBE someday we'll add it to the backlog of things to fix.


    Here's what I want to know...who the heck asked for this stupid enhancement in the first place? How did this get prioritized over literally anything else on the backlog of feature requests? Seriously, how? Who said "I'd like you to take this usable feature that is not perfect (should have been collapsed tree view) and make it frustratingly unusable by having it be search only, but the search will be horrible and hardly ever find the desired target sheet even when you type the sheet name in exactly." Who asked for this insanity, and why doesn't Smartsheet care that their "upgrade" made the functionality measurably worse? WHY???

  • Enoch Mak
    Options

    All for the old way... i'm struggling to find my old sheets and relinking them

  • Jeremy Norman
    Options

    Agree...UI is not good.

  • MCorbin
    MCorbin Overachievers Alumni
    Options

    YES!!! PLEASE!!!!!

    If you have several sheets with similar names (e.g. sheet name - Q1, sheet name - Q2), you can't see the full name in the Move Row box in the automation (you used to be able to hover over it to see the full name), nor, if you click on "Change" does it pick your original sheet in the workspace to allow you to see what's selected or select a new one. This is driving me CRAZY!


  • Jimmy_B
    Jimmy_B ✭✭✭✭
    Options

    Count me as another who is dismayed that this has been changed to remove the tree view. I'm all for a search option but not at the expense of removing the full location information of the sheet you are selecting. If/when moving a row this could cause absolute havoc to a users solution if they select the incorrect sheet.

    I saw that a response says there is no intention on revising this function, that is extremely disappointing from a customer focus/service perspective that this stance would be taken. It seems clear that the community are raising the issue that this is not usable in the area it has been deployed. It may not be a case of reverting to the previous design but looking at what the current can become e.g. make the full path to the sheet available. This, however, would not resolve the issue for users who have a count of sheets with the same name that exceeds the results limit.

    Will keep this bookmarked to track any update (whilst I try and workout how on earth I will pick the correct sheet to copy rows to)

  • Mike TV
    Mike TV ✭✭✭✭✭✭
    Options

    Typically when I'm setting up a Copy Row or Move Row automation, I'm doing it for archive sheet purposes. So I'm creating the archive sheet and then going directly back to the original sheet and setting up the automation to move rows to the archive sheet. My experience with setting up the automation has been to hammer away at the search for about 10 minutes until the new archive sheet finally shows up.

    What a fabulous waste of my time I am enjoying with this nice change!

  • Jesus-LLTK
    Jesus-LLTK ✭✭✭
    Options

    This was not ignored right? I hate to be the one to bump an old post but it is still proven to be an issue for my team to this day.


    My biggest complaint is having the same file name same folder name structure in 1 workspace or separate workspaces that I have for each of my locations, except it's all good when you look at the tree. If based on a name like screenshot provided by Joseph then I'm all out of luck.

    2nd complaint is why are we not given better information as to which sheet the copy/move to is going? I cannot for the life of me ever know where it's going unless I redo the entire selection of going through the search and selecting the sheet. A good structure would be to see the full name, at least on 'hover', followed by the location of that file just like how file>properties>location works.


  • Rick Olsen
    Rick Olsen ✭✭✭✭
    Options

    The option of having the dropdown is great when you don't remember the name or there are a ton of items matching.

    This have been a true pain at times.