Need help with complex workflow

Determining the most efficient workflow and automations for both OTTA and SME (Subject Matter Experts e.g. OPP/OCE/ODGA colleagues) evaluation of LinkedIn Learning materials.
β€’ Two Smartsheets (1A and 1B) are feeding into the SME evaluation Smartsheet (2)
β€’ In Smartsheet 2, we need the SMEs to:
o Self-assign a row for the LinkedIn Learning courses they want to evaluate
o See column information already present (from other sheets)
o Complete additional column information
ο‚§ View instructional information for each column
o Allow a second evaluation of the LinL course
o Automate their recommendations to another sheet {we currently have a workflow automation that moves rows to another sheet}

Our current workflow for Smartsheet 2:
β€’ Uses an automation with an update request once SMEs self-assign
β€’ Has multiple hidden columns (that automatically populate as a result of the automation workflow from the other sheets: 1A and 1B)
β€’ Has an automation workflow to Smartsheet 3 based on field responses

We have not found a solution for the following:
β€’ To have multiple self-assignees for each row
o If an update request form is sent to multiple people from the same row, does Smartsheet save both responses or overwrite?
β€’ To have SME responses be added to current column information rather than replace it
β€’ To provide column-based instructions in the update request
β€’ Is there a way to automate that a full form (not update request) be sent to SMEs when they self-assign? This would allow us to have the full capabilities of a Smartsheet form.

What is a simple, elegant solution to give our SMEs a clear and focused way to fill out this information without them having to write paragraphs directly into the spreadsheet?

Answers