Subtraction using a column with a formula

For some reason I cannot use a subtraction formula when pulling the info from a column that has an existing formula. Is that a thing or am I doing something wrong?

I'm using the simple formula below

=[PCA In service required]@row - [In service hours completed]@row


Best Answer

  • Genevieve P.
    Genevieve P. Employee
    Answer ✓

    Hi @Tzippy

    It's the quotes around your numbers that turns them into text. For example:

    IF(CONTAINS("PCA", Discipline@row), "6"

    Should be

    IF(CONTAINS("PCA", Discipline@row), 6


    Try adjusting that formula to be this:

    =IF(AND([Most recent hire date]@row < DATE(YEAR(TODAY()), 4, 1)), IF(CONTAINS("PCA", Discipline@row), 6), IF(AND([Most recent hire date]@row >= DATE(YEAR(TODAY()), 4, 1), [Most recent hire date]@row < DATE(YEAR(TODAY()), 10, 1)), IF(CONTAINS("PCA", Discipline@row), 3), IF(AND([Most recent hire date]@row >= DATE(YEAR(TODAY()), 10, 1), [Most recent hire date]@row < DATE(YEAR(TODAY()), 12, 31)), IF(CONTAINS("PCA", Discipline@row), 0))))


    Cheers,

    Genevieve

    Join us for Jumpstart 2025 with Community on 23 January (in two time zones)! 🎉 Register here.

Answers

  • =Chris Palmer
    =Chris Palmer ✭✭✭✭✭
    edited 09/08/22

    Hello @Tzippy

    I think this is likely because in the "PCA In Service Required" column, there is a function (the small fx symbol) below the column name.


    This is a shot in the dark, but perhaps we can try something like this:

    =VALUE([PCA In service required]@row) - [In service hours completed]@row

    Hope this helps!

    https://www.linkedin.com/in/zchrispalmer/

  • Hi @Mr. Chris

    The fx just means that there is a column formula I believe...

    I tried your formula but got the invalid operation error message.

    Any other ideas?

  • Hi @Tzippy

    I agree that it looks like your column formula is turning your number into a text value. You can see this because the number appears on the left side of the cell instead of the right.

    The VALUE() function should have converted it back to being a number. Since that didn't work, can you post what formula you're using in the "PCA in service required" column? We may be able to adjust that formula to ensure the output is numerical (e.g. removing any quotes around it).

    Cheers,

    Genevieve

    Join us for Jumpstart 2025 with Community on 23 January (in two time zones)! 🎉 Register here.

  • Hi @Genevieve P.

    The formula in the pca in service column is:

    =IF(AND([Most recent hire date]@row < DATE(YEAR(TODAY()), 4, 1)), IF(CONTAINS("PCA", Discipline@row), "6"), IF(AND([Most recent hire date]@row >= DATE(YEAR(TODAY()), 4, 1), [Most recent hire date]@row < DATE(YEAR(TODAY()), 10, 1)), IF(CONTAINS("PCA", Discipline@row), "3"), IF(AND([Most recent hire date]@row >= DATE(YEAR(TODAY()), 10, 1), [Most recent hire date]@row < DATE(YEAR(TODAY()), 12, 31)), IF(CONTAINS("PCA", Discipline@row), "0"))))

  • Genevieve P.
    Genevieve P. Employee
    Answer ✓

    Hi @Tzippy

    It's the quotes around your numbers that turns them into text. For example:

    IF(CONTAINS("PCA", Discipline@row), "6"

    Should be

    IF(CONTAINS("PCA", Discipline@row), 6


    Try adjusting that formula to be this:

    =IF(AND([Most recent hire date]@row < DATE(YEAR(TODAY()), 4, 1)), IF(CONTAINS("PCA", Discipline@row), 6), IF(AND([Most recent hire date]@row >= DATE(YEAR(TODAY()), 4, 1), [Most recent hire date]@row < DATE(YEAR(TODAY()), 10, 1)), IF(CONTAINS("PCA", Discipline@row), 3), IF(AND([Most recent hire date]@row >= DATE(YEAR(TODAY()), 10, 1), [Most recent hire date]@row < DATE(YEAR(TODAY()), 12, 31)), IF(CONTAINS("PCA", Discipline@row), 0))))


    Cheers,

    Genevieve

    Join us for Jumpstart 2025 with Community on 23 January (in two time zones)! 🎉 Register here.

  • @Genevieve P.

    Yes!! That worked!! I had no idea about this quotations and on which side of the cell the number is! Thanks for teaching me that and your patience for helping me with this!!

  • No problem! I'm glad to hear it worked 🙂

    Join us for Jumpstart 2025 with Community on 23 January (in two time zones)! 🎉 Register here.

Help Article Resources

Want to practice working with formulas directly in Smartsheet?

Check out the Formula Handbook template!