Dynamic View: Adding Field Logic

I have added the following Field Logic to have certain fields required on the form when another field is marked proposed. However, with the following logic applied, the form is still able to be saved w/out those fields being completed.. even though I indicated on the form the status is proposed. Is there a reason this is not working? I do not want a user to be able to save the form unless those fields are completed. *Note I can not mark them required initially, because they are only required when the entry is actually "Proposed". Can anyone assist?


  • Genevieve P.
    Genevieve P. Employee Admin

    Hi @dwallerius98081

    Field Logic in Dynamic View works differently than Conditional Logic in forms. In order for the field to recognize a new entry, the entry needs to be saved, submitting this value to the underlying sheet. Once that value is input to the cell/underlying sheet, the field logic can identify the value and apply logic to the View Panel.

    What this means is that after the Status has been updated and saved, then you'll see the next two fields as required.

    So, if someone had previously submitted the information on this row, and the status shows "Proposed", then when a user clicks on that row in Dynamic View then the logic in the Panel shows these fields as required. If, however, the user filling in the panel is the one who is switching the Status, the fields will only show once they hit the Save button and the new value has been entered to the sheet.

    You may want to add helper text to your fields to identify this and ask your users to click "save" after each entry. Or if this is the initial intake of the row, you could set up a Form from the underlying sheet as the intake form instead of the Panel.

    I hope this helps clarify how the Panel works!



  • Please change Field Logic in Dynamic Views to match Conditional Login in forms. The way it works now does not make any sense. Field logic should be applied both when the form loads with any existing data as well as when the user changes the value in a drop down field.

    The current approach also doesn't work well with other automation, which may be triggered based on a change to a status column. The assumption may be that when the status column changes other values will be updated as well, but there is no guarantee that will happen.

  • Felicia Wilson
    Felicia Wilson ✭✭✭✭✭✭

    I agree with Mark Salamon. The way the field logic in dynamic views works is not user friendly. Asking a user to save after each entry is a way to frustrate a user quickly. the way the conditional logic on the forms works is much better where the logic is applied as the user changes the value in the drop down field.

  • +1 for this enhancement = as I was looking for this very functionality.

    I want to make a field required in Dynamic View if a user makes a specific selection.

    if it only applies after they save their selection it defeats the purpose.


  • Jarrod Dorney
    Jarrod Dorney ✭✭✭✭✭✭

    +1 for this enhancement.

    Great work guys... Smartsheet please find a way to improve the display panel in Dynamic View to better reflect how a form displays when using conditional formatting, its no good having conditional formatting requiring an additional field to be filled but the sheet saving halfway through the process. Thanks.

  • Traci Summers
    Traci Summers ✭✭✭✭✭✭

    +1 as well

    I've been waiting for this functionality to be released for almost 2 years. Most of what we use Dynamic view would benefits for an immediate calculation so entries could be modified to fit guidelines we've set. I can build all the formulas and controls into the Smartsheet, but because I need Dynamic View to handle the security, I lose all that functionality.